Writers from Timeform and Sporting Life discuss their Cheltenham favourites

Cheltenham Festival GOATs: Is Big Buck's the greatest Cheltenham horse of all time?


This article was originally published prior to the 2026 Cheltenham Festival

Read tributes to Big Buck's from trainer Paul Nicholls here


Why is Big Buck’s the greatest Cheltenham horse of all time?

Anybody marking this answer with dogma is probably kidding themselves given the wealth of alternatives in Cheltenham’s long and rich history. But a record reading four successive World Hurdles (as it was called then, before reverting back to Stayers’ Hurdle in recent years) when no other winner of that race – even Baracouda - going back to its inception in the 1910s has won more than two in a row speaks for itself, trumping the achievements of fellow staying great Inglis Drever, whose trio of successes in the race were spread across four years following his defeat when bidding for a hat-trick in 2006.

And, from a wider perspective, those four World Hurdles at the track came amidst an eighteen-race winning sequence that began in a handicap at Cheltenham on New Year’s Day 2009 and wasn’t ended until his return from an injury-enforced absence in the Cleeve Hurdle on Trials’ Day at the track half a decade later. In all, Big Buck’s won seven times at Cheltenham and met with defeat there only once his powers had waned due to that leg injury.

Big Buck's leads over the lat


Was he not just a failed Gold Cup horse? Like Ted Walsh famously said, nobody bred a horse to win a Stayers' Hurdle...

Well there are two ways of reading that. And I know which side I’m on!

Firstly, the reality of it is that the brilliance of Big Buck’s as a hurdler meant we never got to find out if he was a Gold Cup horse or not! And who’s to say with certainty that he couldn’t have become one? In fact, that may be the only ‘what might have been’ aspect of his illustrious career, as he was a Grade 1 winner over fences as a novice and might well have won a Hennessy from a BHA mark of 153 first time out the following season had he not unseated Sam Thomas at the last, a departure that ultimately led to the change of path to hurdling that essentially changed the course of Cheltenham Festival history itself.

There can surely be no doubt whatsoever, either, that the Cheltenham Gold Cup trip would have been firmly in the favour of a stayer whose subsequent dominance of the staying hurdle scene was characterised by a finishing effort so strong that even other thorough stayers couldn’t contain him. But, as a riposte to Ted Walsh and any other naysayers, there are countless Cheltenham greats whose legacy isn’t diminished by them earning their stripes winning races other than the Gold Cup and, equally, there are many winners of the figurehead race at the meeting (Cool Dawn and Lord Windermere, anyone?) who, in terms of ability and impact, wouldn’t be fit to shod the hooves of Big Buck’s, let alone be mentioned in the same sentence.

Delete caption


Did he even beat much over hurdles? Wasn’t he just bullying inferior rivals in that division?

I’d say a sample size covering four years of Cheltenham Festival success, brushing aside every new face from the previous season’s novice ranks who was tasked with taking him on in open company, is sufficiently large to suggest Big Buck’s did vastly more than bully inferiors.

Indeed, his first venture into a graded staying hurdle, in the 2009 Cleeve Hurdle at Cheltenham, Big Buck’s lowered the colours of odds-on Punchestowns, who remained antepost favourite for the World Hurdle in the aftermath having surged to the top of the standings in the division himself when, on only his second start in open company, he’d run out an emphatic winner of Ascot’s Long Walk Hurdle over Christmas, giving an eleven-length beating to stablemate Due de Regniere (five-length winner of Long Distance Hurdle at Newbury time before), with the previous season’s Punchestown Grade 1 World Series winner, Blazing Bailey, roughly half as far further back in fourth.

The fundamental basis for assessing merit objectively is via ratings, and a peak Timeform figure of 176 puts the greatness of Big Buck’s beyond any doubt; when the few positioned higher in a list of the best hurdlers of all time includes the likes of Night Nurse, Istabraq and Persian War, then a firm ‘no’ to the notion of merely dominating a weak era is surely the correct answer.

Andy Stewart (left) celebrates after Big Buck's wins The Ladbrokes World Hurdle in 2012


He certainly came along during a vintage period for the Paul Nicholls yard didn’t he?

Nicholls has been surpassed – as everyone else has for that matter – in terms of Cheltenham Festival success by Willie Mullins. But even the most dominant trainer of modern times arguably never had a spell of such sustained domination in the very best open Grade 1 races as Nicholls had during that golden period for the stable.

Across the same span that Big Buck’s won his four World Hurdles from 2009 and 2012, Master Minded landed the first of his back-to-back Champion Chase successes in 2008, the same year crowd favourite Denman won his Cheltenham Gold Cup, a success sandwiched between two in the great race for Kauto Star, the best horse Nicholls has ever trained and one of the very best of all time, with a Timeform rating of 191 accrued in a career featuring a remarkable sixteen Grade 1 wins – including a record five King George’s – fully 9 lb higher than that awarded to Douven, who remains the highest-rated jumper to have been trained by Mullins.


Sounds like there’s plenty to choose from, but what’s your favourite Big Buck’s moment?

Big Buck’s was one of those rarities whose winning performances seemed to create an energy that could be carried to living rooms – or in our case, offices - across the country, such was the roar that his trademark late surge would elicit from the paying crowd on track. But there’s still no substitute for being there and, without needing a penny on him, his fourth and final success in the World Hurdle is always my go-to response on this topic.

Firstly, there’s the visceral experience of watching an all-time great perform in a style that became so metronomic during his stranglehold on the division; that moment that prompts a cry of ‘here he comes’ or a ‘he’s got him’, with the added dimension in 2012 of a final challenger – Voler La Vedette – having a late crack that ultimately came up short after Big Buck’s had already hit the front and started to motor running to the last.

‘Inevitable’ summed up Big Buck’s so well. And then there’s the immediacy of being present when history has been created, and at the finest meeting of them all to boot In fact, I still have the footage on my phone I filmed as he returned to the Winners’ Enclosure that day, a sound surpassed in my years of visiting Cheltenham only by the reception Rachael Blackmore and Honeysuckle received following her win in the 2023 Mares Hurdle. More than a decade has passed since Big Buck’s retired and only one horse – Flooring Porter - has managed to win more than one Stayers’ Hurdle during that time. There may never be another like him.


MOST READ RACING

Next Off

Image of a white chevron pointing towards the right.

Going

:

Surface

: -
Horse silk
Horse silk
Horse silk

RACING TIPS

Join for Free
Image of stables faded in a gold gradientGet exclusive Willie Mullins insight, plus access to premium articles, expert tips and Timeform data, plus more...
Log in
Discover Sporting Life Plus benefitsWhite Chevron
Sporting Life Plus Logo