Marco Silva's Everton future: David Moyes favourite but Toffees should be patient as perfect candidate is not there

Could David Moyes replace Marco Silva?
Could David Moyes replace Marco Silva?

The end seems in sight for Marco Silva, but The Athletic's Greg O'Keefe says the club's main problem is there are no suitable replacements who could unite the fans at Goodison.

David Moyes would be Everton’s first choice to replace Marco Silva if the club decide to remove their struggling manager, and although he would get a mixed reception, ideal candidates are hard to find.

We spoke to The Athletic’s Everton correspondent Greg O’Keefe to get the inside track on the managerial situation at Goodison Park, with the Toffees just one place outside the relegation zone after a heart-breaking loss at Leicester.

There’s a difficult run of fixtures coming up for Silva’s side and the Everton board may be tempted to make a switch should results continue to go against them, and it seems as though former boss Moyes is the first choice replacement – even if just on an interim basis.

Moyes, though, may be looking for something more permanent.

“Interestingly, it’s whether David Moyes wants an interim position or something permanent, and whether Everton are willing to acquiesce to that and give him something a bit more permanent,” O’Keefe told Sporting Life.

“But his name is at the top of the list should they turn to an interim manager.”


Next manager to leave odds

  • 1/3 Marco Silva
  • 4/1 Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
  • 8/1 Brendan Rodgers
  • 12/1 Manuel Pellegrini | Nuno Espirito Santo | Rapplh Hasenhuttl

Click here for the full market


Patience and a cool head, though, was what The Athletic’s Everton man would like to see employed in this situation, even if it means sticking with Silva until the end of the season.

“They’ve got a very challenging run of fixtures and you could mount an argument that they’re not going to get any wins out of those games so then you are possibly in a relegation fight,” he added.

“For me it makes more sense to stick with Marco Silva until the end of the season, barring the risk of a genuine battle to stay up, then make a cool headed decision to see if he’s achieved his targets from last summer.

The latest Sporting Life Premier League Weekly podcast
The latest Sporting Life Premier League Weekly podcast

“Then if you say OK let’s move on, you have a new coach who can come in and have a full summer to prepare and hopefully take the club on.”

It certainly looks like the end of the line for Silva though, and O’Keefe says the biggest problem for the Everton board is that there is no obvious choice that would be universally popular with the fans.

“I don’t believe it’s gone as bad as it had got for previous managers, such as Roberto Martinez, as that was toxic towards the end of his tenure.

“It’s not that bad for Silva, but it is bad, it’s very rare you’ll see home fans joining in with away fans singing “you’re getting sacked in the morning” as they have done.

“He hasn’t lost them all but he’s lost a significant portion of the fans. It feels like we’re in the end game for Marco Silva.

Who will be the next manager to leave their post in the Premier League?
Who will be the next manager to leave their post in the Premier League?

“Fans want some elite manager, but unfortunately in the real world managers like that aren’t going to come here right now.

“I would suggest that you couldn’t find a candidate that would unite the fans at the moment, and that’s the challenge for the board, so I couldn’t even give you a realistic name that everyone would agree on right now.

“What I would like if for Marcel Brands, who was brought to the club with his great pedigree, to be able to do his job and select the next couch and we can all get behind him and respect his choice.”

Follow Sporting Life on social media - find us on Facebook here or tweet @SportingLifeFC

Related football links

Like what you've read?
Help your friends Know It All by sharing this article to your social media.

Most Read Football

The Sporting Life team provide their free tips for Saturday's action across a range of sports1

Saturday's Bets of the Day

Our writers combine to pick out Saturday's best betting opportunities, with racing selections from Sandown to Wolverhampton and our take on the Manchester derby.

The latest Sporting Life football Accumulator2

Sporting Life Accumulator

We're back to a full fixture list this weekend meaning the latest Sporting Life Accumulator involves four teams from across the divisions.

The Manchester derby is one of Saturday's games3

Saturday's Premier League tips

Mark your card for Saturday's Premier League games with Tom Carnduff providing his best bets and score predictions for each clash.

Marcelo Gallardo after winning the CONMEBOL Recopa Sudamericana 20194

Arsenal must look to Gallardo

Arsenal continue in their hunt for a new manager following the sacking of Unai Emery. Tom Carnduff believes they should appoint Marcelo Gallardo.

Nigel Pearson5

Pearson takes charge of Watford

Watford have appointed Nigel Pearson as head coach, initially until the end of the season, the Premier League club have announced.

Most Read Football

The Sporting Life team provide their free tips for Saturday's action across a range of sports1

Saturday's Bets of the Day

Our writers combine to pick out Saturday's best betting opportunities, with racing selections from Sandown to Wolverhampton and our take on the Manchester derby.

The latest Sporting Life football Accumulator2

Sporting Life Accumulator

We're back to a full fixture list this weekend meaning the latest Sporting Life Accumulator involves four teams from across the divisions.

The Manchester derby is one of Saturday's games3

Saturday's Premier League tips

Mark your card for Saturday's Premier League games with Tom Carnduff providing his best bets and score predictions for each clash.

Marcelo Gallardo after winning the CONMEBOL Recopa Sudamericana 20194

Arsenal must look to Gallardo

Arsenal continue in their hunt for a new manager following the sacking of Unai Emery. Tom Carnduff believes they should appoint Marcelo Gallardo.

Nigel Pearson5

Pearson takes charge of Watford

Watford have appointed Nigel Pearson as head coach, initially until the end of the season, the Premier League club have announced.

Football Tips

The latest Sporting Life football Accumulator

Sporting Life Accumulator

We're back to a full fixture list this weekend meaning the latest Sporting Life Accumulator involves four teams from across the divisions.

The Manchester derby is one of Saturday's games

Saturday's Premier League tips

Mark your card for Saturday's Premier League games with Tom Carnduff providing his best bets and score predictions for each clash.

Our best bets in the Sky Bet EFL

Sky Bet EFL: Weekend preview

We're back to a full round of fixtures following the FA Cup weekend. Tom Carnduff picks out his best bets in the Sky Bet EFL.