Alex Ferguson and Jose Mourinho

What if Jose Mourinho had taken over from Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United?


Jose Mourinho receives a call from his greatest hero, the man he is now honoured to call a friend, Sir Alex Ferguson, and is told that he - a serial winner at Porto, Chelsea, Inter Milan, and Real Madrid - has been handpicked to be Fergie’s successor.

Manchester United are the biggest football club in the world and Jose Mourinho is the best football manager in the world. The Special One is the Chosen One.

It is the perfect match. And football history changes forever.

When it was revealed on Monday in a teaser for an upcoming Netflix documentary that Jose had indeed turned down the job offer before it was given to David Moyes (revealed by Mourinho himself, then confirmed by Sir Alex) it was easier to roll your eyes and make the counterfactual.

Man Utd were old and haggard, their crisis inevitable. Hiring Mourinho would only exacerbate the horrors, as we ought to know having watched him fail in the job only three years later.

But that argument makes the classic mistake of outcome bias, assuming history has a fatalistic aspect. It is far more likely Mourinho would have been a success, the knock-on effect of which is difficult to fathom.

Recall that Man Utd had just won the title in 2012/13, maximising the defensive intelligence in those ageing legs at the back and sprinkling a bit of counter-attacking dust at the other end via a peak Wayne Rooney and Robin van Persie (remind you of anyone?).

Recall that in 2013 Mourinho was still a genius, a man who had succeeded in every single job since winning the Champions League with Porto a decade earlier.

Recall that two years later he would win the Premier League title as Chelsea manager.

The squad Moyes inherited was not bad, it simply lacked its leader. The stories about Moyes being overawed have been (very) well documented in endless Class of 92 podcasts but nobody – nobody – has stories like that about Mourinho, an authority figure who had the charisma, tight leash, and single-mindedness required to stamp his authority on the Old Trafford dressing room.

Indeed he was probably the only manager in the world with the personality to manage a post-Ferguson United.

https://www.sportinglife.com/football/fixtures-results

Better still, Mourinho had exactly the tactical beliefs required to get the best out of an experienced set of players best suited to sitting off in a 4-4-2 and hitting on the break, being Ferguson’s closest tactical equivalent at the time.

It really was the perfect fit on every conceivable level - including transfers.

New chief executive Ed Woodward infamously failed spectacularly in the transfer market in his debut summer and, with as few contacts and as little experience in the area as Moyes, came away from a hopeless summer with only Marouane Fellaini to show for it.

Mourinho would surely have led here, convincing long-time target Cesc Fabregas to join (as he did at Chelsea 12 months later) and probably continuing with the Thiago Alcantara deal that Woodward inexplicably pulled out of.

Straight away that’s the midfield sorted. A centre-back and a creative midfielder is all that would have been required, and it’s worth nothing that Marquinhos and Mesut Ozil made moves that summer.

Mourinho is the master of signing two or three ready-made stars to fill the gaps for a ruthless charge to the title, so there is every reason to assume he would have shown those talents again.

And to top it off, he would have done so in a weakened Premier League field.

David Moyes and Jose Mourinho
David Moyes became United boss instead of Jose Mourinho

In the three seasons after 2012/13 the Premier League title was won by Manuel Pellegrini (86 points), Mourinho (87 points), and Claudio Ranieri (81 points).

So dismal was the quality it culminated in Leicester's fairytale win, in turn triggering a long-overdue tactical investment in England with Antonio Conte, Pep Guardiola, and Jurgen Klopp the cavalry arriving to reshape the game.

By then Mourinho, of course, would be out.

Three years is his maximum but it is not inconceivable that - with the foundations in place and command of the transfer market, and quietly tempered by landing his dream job with his quasi-mentor watching his every move from the stands - Mourinho and United win all three.

History spirals out of control at this juncture. At Old Trafford there is no Louis van Gaal and, of course, the butterfly effect means everything United is changed beyond recognition.

But there is also no Leicester title. No Steven Gerrard slip. No Kevin De Bruyne or Mohamed Salah leaving Mourinho’s Chelsea.

And what happens if a successful Mourinho eventually implodes around 2016. First of all, Mourinho is available just as the England job is about to fall into Sam Allardyce’s lap.

As for the vacant United post, is that role more appealing to Pep Guardiola?

Even if that’s a step too far, the 13-year circus that is Manchester United probably would never have happened. The original fall averted, the transition from Ferguson seamless, Woodward would have used the Mourinho template to hire from the very top in 2015 or 2016, if not Guardiola then Conte, Klopp, or Carlo Ancelotti.

The whole world changed with a single decision.

It’s hard to believe now that back in 2013 Man Utd, winners of 13 of the past 21 titles, had wealth and power so great they could – should – have continued to monopolise the Premier League.

If only his love of Chelsea hadn’t got in the way, Mourinho would have pulled it off.


More from Sporting Life


Safer gambling

We are committed in our support of safer gambling. Recommended bets are advised to over-18s and we strongly encourage readers to wager only what they can afford to lose.

If you are concerned about your gambling, please call the National Gambling Helpline / GamCare on 0808 8020 133.

Further support and information can be found at begambleaware.org and gamblingtherapy.org.


Like what you've read?

MOST READ FOOTBALL

Join for Free
Image of stables faded in a gold gradientGet exclusive Willie Mullins insight, plus access to premium articles, expert tips and Timeform data, plus more...
Log in
Discover Sporting Life Plus benefitsWhite Chevron
Sporting Life Plus Logo

FOOTBALL TIPS