Most Read Football

Joelinton scores for Newcastle against Tottenham1

Joelinton lifts the Toon gloom

Joelinton's goal stunned Spurs as Newcastle lifted some of the gloom around Steve Bruce with a hard-fought 1-0 win at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.

Sporting Life picks out the top five events or fixtures of the week not to be missed2

Five for the week: Aug 26-Sep 1

Our 'Five for the Week' looks ahead to another exciting week of sport, including Premier League football, more top-class golf and the return of F1.

Raul Jimenez celebrates scoring for Wolves against Burnley at Molineux3

Raul rescues a point for Wolves

Burnley were denied an impressive win at Molineux as Raul Jimenez scored a dramatic stoppage-time penalty to give Wolves a 1-1 draw.

Premier League and EFL football gossip and transfer rumours4

Paper Talk: PSG target Zaha

Paris Saint-Germain are planning a shock £100m move for Crystal Palace's Wilfried Zaha - get all the latest from Sunday's back pages.

We celebrate the best bets that have come in over weekend5

Weekend Winners: Ebor extra strong

Two of our racing team marked the first £1million edition of the Sky Bet Ebor by tipping the winner as we close in on an almighty August. Get details in Weekend Winners.

Harry Maguire at Manchester United: Can the world's most expensive defender be as good as Virgil van Dijk at Liverpool?

Harry Maguire impressed on his Manchester United debut but can he compare to Virgil van Dijk?
Harry Maguire impressed on his Manchester United debut but can he compare to Virgil van Dijk?

Can Harry Maguire have the same impact on Manchester United that Virgil van Dijk had at Liverpool? After a very encouraging debut the instant reaction is that the England man may be able to do just that.

A few words that popped up in the immediate post-match analysis of Maguire’s debut against Chelsea hold the key really – presence, solid, dependable were all mentioned when rating the former Leicester City man, all overshadowing what he actually did on the pitch.

Getting the Man of the Match award ahead of Marcus Rashford and Anthony Martial was laughable, but it perhaps points to Maguire starting off on a similar path to Van Dijk, who has grown to become a super-human presence in the middle of Liverpool’s defence.

Perception is everything in football and in this world of media extremes, Van Dijk has gone from overpriced to irreplaceable in 18 months – Maguire and United will hope he’s just taken the first step on a similar career arc.

In truth, Maguire had a decent debut, not an overly flashy one, as early nerves and an understandable lack of cohesion could have led to a couple of Chelsea goals, but once they were ahead the Red Devils looked a lot more comfortable.

Style of play under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer will help. Leicester often sat back deep and compact and sprung forward on the counter-attack – at times being led by Maguire striding out of defence with the ball at his feet. United will play a similar way from what we saw at Old Trafford on Sunday.

Harry Maguire’s debut – What they said

"He's done exactly what we signed him for," United boss Solskjaer said. "His presence in both boxes, his composure and calmness on the ball, and he is a leader."

More key words here – “presence, composure, calmness” three things that United’s defence lacked on more than a few occasions last season.

Jose Mourinho couldn’t help but mention that he had wanted to sign Maguire 12 months before he finally arrived – and how things may have been different had he got his man…

"He was solid like a rock," declared Mourinho through ever-so-slightly gritted teeth.

"You can be very dangerous in attack but if you feel that a mistake is around the corner it takes your confidence away and you don't play as well. When you feel there is something that allows you to play you are much more confident.

"As I always said, Lindelof can be a very good player. With Maguire it can be a very good partnership."

Former Foxes team-mate and also ex-Man Utd man Jonny Evans feels that Maguire is the perfect fit for Solskjaer’s side and sees comparisons with Van Dijk.

"You can see comparisons in their games, both are great on the ball, and Harry has got explosive pace people don't see," he said.

"He is powerful, good in the air...Everyone will compare the transfer fees but it's so difficult to judge transfer fees nowadays. The most important thing is for him to be judged on how he plays. I don't have any worries about him there.

"He is tailor-made for Man United, it was a great move for him. He's a player they needed.”

Maguire’s role at Man Utd

Supply-and-demand dictated that Maguire cost United £80m, whether he is truly worth that amount is largely irrelevant, but £80m will be money well spent if he can bring a real change in his new team’s overall defending.

He’ll have to get used to having more pressure on his shoulders, and he’ll have to get used to being the centre of attention and more importantly a role model and leader of that defence at Old Trafford.

As well as his defending, Van Dijk’s greatest strength is that he elevates the players around him as he exudes confidence and there was a visible lift in Liverpool’s defending from the very first moment he stepped onto the pitch in red.

Manchester United's Harry Maguire and Liverpool's Virgil van Dijk are both big-money signings
Can Manchester United's Harry Maguire be as good as Liverpool's Virgil van Dijk?

It’s not enough, then, for Maguire to come in and just give seven or eight-out-of-ten performances week-in and week-out, he has to be both excellent himself and instil excellence in his defensive partners for him to be seen as a success.

With Aaron Wan-Bissaka and Luke Shaw he has pace at full-back but also young players that will need pointing in the right direction in terms of positioning – Maguire had to fill in for Shaw a couple of times against Chelsea but swept up well.

The signing could also be the making of Victor Lindelof – a player Mourinho insisted was good enough to become a regular United centre half and one who could very much do with a calming influence alongside him.

Linedlof has plenty of defensive attributes but does lack maturity and a touch of patience – if having Maguire around can just improve him in those areas then Solskjaer could well have a decent partnership on his hands.

Maguire’s ability to come out with the ball is a talent, but first and foremost he has to defend, and help his fellow defenders to improve and come together as a unit.

Van Dijk has done that with Liverpool and, while Maguire is not at that level yet, if he can bring that assured presence (there’s that word again) to their defence then £80m could soon look like money well spent.

LISTEN: Our football team run through the latest news, views and incidents from the Premier League
LISTEN: Our football team run through the latest news, views and incidents from the Premier League

Follow Sporting Life on social media - find us on Facebook here or tweet@SportingLifeFC

Related football links

Like what you've read?
Help your friends Know It All by sharing this article to your social media.

Most Read Football

Joelinton scores for Newcastle against Tottenham1

Joelinton lifts the Toon gloom

Joelinton's goal stunned Spurs as Newcastle lifted some of the gloom around Steve Bruce with a hard-fought 1-0 win at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.

Sporting Life picks out the top five events or fixtures of the week not to be missed2

Five for the week: Aug 26-Sep 1

Our 'Five for the Week' looks ahead to another exciting week of sport, including Premier League football, more top-class golf and the return of F1.

Raul Jimenez celebrates scoring for Wolves against Burnley at Molineux3

Raul rescues a point for Wolves

Burnley were denied an impressive win at Molineux as Raul Jimenez scored a dramatic stoppage-time penalty to give Wolves a 1-1 draw.

Premier League and EFL football gossip and transfer rumours4

Paper Talk: PSG target Zaha

Paris Saint-Germain are planning a shock £100m move for Crystal Palace's Wilfried Zaha - get all the latest from Sunday's back pages.

We celebrate the best bets that have come in over weekend5

Weekend Winners: Ebor extra strong

Two of our racing team marked the first £1million edition of the Sky Bet Ebor by tipping the winner as we close in on an almighty August. Get details in Weekend Winners.

Football Tips

Justin Thomas celebrates

Sporting Life Tipping Record

A look at how the Sporting Life recommended bets have performed in August 2019.

All of Sporting Life's current best bets across a range of sports

Our best bets

Check out Sporting Life's best bets across racing, football and more.

Sporting Life's Premier League preview package

Super Sunday: Spurs set to shine

More Premier League games on Sunday to get stuck into and we're backing Spurs to inflict more misery on Steve Bruce's Newcastle.