Ferrari fail in appeal against Sebastian Vettel penalty in Canada

Sebastian Vettel takes matters into his own hands
Sebastian Vettel takes matters into his own hands

Ferrari have lost their review into Sebastian Vettel's five-second penalty at the Canadian Grand Prix, confirming Lewis Hamilton as the race winner.

Twelve days after Vettel was demoted to runner-up in Montreal, punished for rejoining the circuit in a dangerous manner, Ferrari presented new evidence they hoped would overturn the controversial result.

But following a 35-minute presentation by Ferrari's sporting director Laurent Mekies at the Circuit Paul Ricard ahead of this week's French Grand Prix, the stewards took less than two hours to announce their original decision will stand.

A statement from the FIA read: "There are no significant and relevant new elements which were unavailable to the parties at the time of the competition concerned."

The ruling of Formula One's governing body will come as a significant blow to both Vettel and Ferrari, with Mekies having earlier claimed that the team's evidence would prove their star driver's innocence.

"We have requested the FIA's right of review because we believe that this evidence is quite overwhelming when it comes to establishing that Sebastian did not breach any regulations," he said.

Ferrari announced their decision to appeal against Vettel's penalty immediately after the race in Canada before withdrawing their challenge four days later.

However, Article 14 of the FIA's International Sporting Code - the Right of Review - provided them with another avenue to pursue the case if they could unearth significant fresh evidence.

The Scuderia offered what they regarded as seven new elements to the stewards, including telemetry analysis, a variety of video and still images, and GPS data from both Vettel's and Hamilton's cars during the incident on lap 48 in Montreal.

They also included video analysis by Sky Sports' pundit Karun Chandhok - the former grand prix driver who made 11 appearances with a best finish of 14th - as well as footage from Vettel's face camera released after the race.

The stewards dismissed five of the seven elements as being "available before the end of the competition." They added that Vettel's face camera was "new but not significant and relevant as the evidence contained in this video footage can be seen within other available video."

Chandhok's analysis was also deemed irrelevant and simply "a personal opinion by a third party."

Vettel will now head into Sunday's eighth round of the championship in the south of France 62 points behind Hamilton.

Vettel has not won since last August's Belgian Grand Prix - a run of 15 races - while rival Hamilton has triumphed 11 times during that period. His Mercedes team are unbeaten this season.

'Burn the papers'

"No it is not a surprise," said Vettel, reflecting on the verdict.

"We don't share the opinion of the stewards during the race. We thought we could bring something new.

"It is disappointing that it doesn't go further, but that is it, and we have to move on."

Asked how he can change the sport to avoid further penalties, Vettel joked: "Retire. At least then I am not in trouble anymore.

"We have so many pages in our regulations if you want, you find the paragraph that suits. How can you change it? Just burn the papers."

Like what you've read?
Help your friends Know It All by sharing this article to your social media.

Most Read

Sheffield United players celebrate1

Blades too good for blunt Arsenal

Sheffield United claimed the scalp of Arsenal to move up to ninth in the Premier League with a 1-0 victory at Bramall Lane.

Gareth Jones predicts the outcome of the Rugby World Cup semi-finals2

World Cup: Semi-final predictions

Gareth Jones previews the semi-finals of the Rugby Union World Cup as northern and southern hemisphere go head-to-head.

Check out our tips for the Portugal Masters...3

Portugal Masters: Gorgeous George

Birdies are the order of the day at the Portugal Masters, where Ben Coley is backing George Coetzee. Read his in-depth preview.

The view at Exeter racecourse4

Tuesday's racing preview

Equiano Springs can follow up a recent Newmarket win in the Optional Claiming Handicap at Newcastle, according to Anita Chambers.

Check out Tuesday's Champions League preview and best bets5

Tuesday's Champions League tips

The third matchday of the Champions League group stages takes place this week. George Pitts looks ahead to Tuesday's action.

Most Read

Sheffield United players celebrate1

Blades too good for blunt Arsenal

Sheffield United claimed the scalp of Arsenal to move up to ninth in the Premier League with a 1-0 victory at Bramall Lane.

Gareth Jones predicts the outcome of the Rugby World Cup semi-finals2

World Cup: Semi-final predictions

Gareth Jones previews the semi-finals of the Rugby Union World Cup as northern and southern hemisphere go head-to-head.

Check out our tips for the Portugal Masters...3

Portugal Masters: Gorgeous George

Birdies are the order of the day at the Portugal Masters, where Ben Coley is backing George Coetzee. Read his in-depth preview.

The view at Exeter racecourse4

Tuesday's racing preview

Equiano Springs can follow up a recent Newmarket win in the Optional Claiming Handicap at Newcastle, according to Anita Chambers.

Check out Tuesday's Champions League preview and best bets5

Tuesday's Champions League tips

The third matchday of the Champions League group stages takes place this week. George Pitts looks ahead to Tuesday's action.

Racing Tips

The view at Exeter racecourse

Tuesday's racing preview

Equiano Springs can follow up a recent Newmarket win in the Optional Claiming Handicap at Newcastle, according to Anita Chambers.

Sporting Life's NAP of the day

Daily Nap: Eden delights

Matt Brocklebank is backing David Pipe's star bumper performer to get off the mark at the first time of asking over obstacles at Exeter.

Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Alexandre Lacazette celebrate a goal for Arsenal in Valencia

Sporting Life Tipping Record

A look at how the Sporting Life recommended bets have performed in October 2019.

Next Race Off

00:44 Mountaineer
7
(7)
Pep The Champ
J: Alex Gonzalez
6
(6)
Rarified Air
J: Megan Fadlovich

Football Tips

The latest Sporting Life football Accumulator

Sporting Life Accumulator

We have a midweek Sporting Life Accumulator with action in the Sky Bet EFL. A four-fold enhanced to 22/1 with the league sponsors.

Check out Tuesday's Champions League preview and best bets

Tuesday's Champions League tips

The third matchday of the Champions League group stages takes place this week. George Pitts looks ahead to Tuesday's action.

Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Alexandre Lacazette celebrate a goal for Arsenal in Valencia

Sporting Life Tipping Record

A look at how the Sporting Life recommended bets have performed in October 2019.