Scotland 28-17 France: Six Nations result, report, reaction and highlights

Scotland celebrate

Scotland brought France's Grand Slam quest to a shuddering halt as Sean Maitland's try double sealed a 28-17 win at BT Murrayfield.

Scotland 28-17 France

Scotland tryscorers: Maitland (2), McInally
Scotland conversions: Hastings (2)
Scotland penalties: Hastings (3)

France tryscorers: Penaud, Ollivon
France conversions: Jalibert (2)
France penalties: Jalibert

Match report

Scotland brought France's Grand Slam quest to a shuddering halt as Sean Maitland's try double sealed a 28-17 win at BT Murrayfield.

Fabien Galthie's side touched down in Edinburgh looking to take another step towards their first Guinness Six Nations clean sweep in a decade.

They even found themselves ahead midway through the opening half from Damian Penaud's try.

But a defence remodelled in Shaun Edwards' stingy image was left terribly exposed when Mohamed Haouas got himself sent off for an act of sheer stupidity as he aimed a punch at Jamie Ritchie.

Scotland have struggled to make the most of their attacking opportunities this campaign but, with just 14 men to contend with, they finally found their verve. Maitland crossed either side of half-time before Stuart McInally sealed a precious victory.

France had previously toppled England, Italy and Wales but looked out of sorts in the Scottish capital from the off.

The foundations of Les Bleus' success so far had been the twin talents of youngsters Romain Ntamack and Antoine Dupont.

But Ntamack's involvement was limited to 11 rather shambolic minutes. First he skewed wide with a simple penalty, then came a knock-on from a high ball before he finally copped a bang to the head from Sam Johnson which forced him to be replaced.

The visitors were already a man down by this point after flanker Paul Willemse was sent to the bin for dropping Grant Gilchrist on his head.

Kiwi referee Paul Williams decided the tip tackle was clumsy rather than reckless and opted to keep his red in his pocket - but not for long.

The early signs were good for the Scots, with a couple of big shunts from the pack teeing up Adam Hastings to slot over a penalty on 11 minutes. He added another seven minutes later as his forwards continued to pilfer and frustrate at the breakdown.

However, while Ntamack's departure was a blow to France, they had another exciting young pivot to call on in the shape of Matthieu Jalibert and it was his combination with Arthur Vincent that saw the visitors grab the lead against the run of play.

Scotland were cut apart down the left and the broken field was manna from heaven for Dupont, with his kick to the opposite flank drawing Blair Kinghorn into no-man's land as Penaud scored on 33 minutes.

France felt the tide had turned in their favour - but then came Haouas' moment of madness.

An off-the-ball squabble of pushes and shoves suddenly exploded into a furious row when the prop threw a punch at Ritchie's chin. Williams took his time reviewing the images on the big screen but was left with no choice but to flash red when the cameras caught Haouas' haymaker in HD quality.

Once the commotion was cleared, Hastings nudged Scotland back ahead with a penalty.

And it took Townsend's team just four minutes to make use of the extra room as Maitland struck on the stroke of half-time.

Hastings punctured Les Bleus' line with a daring break and Scotland did not hang about to let the visitors regroup as Stuart Hogg and Johnson snapped the ball out to the Saracens wing to score in the corner.

That put Scotland seven up at the break - and the lead was doubled just five minutes into the second period as Maitland grabbed another.

A kicking duel between the teams was going nowhere until Hogg sensed his moment to surge forward. Chris Harris took the drive on before Ali Price scampered to within five yards of the whitewash.

Again Scotland were quick to spot the space on the wing as Maitland stretched to dot down a try, converted by Hastings.

A Jalibert penalty trimmed the deficit by three but Scotland stuck another seven onto their tally on 65 minutes as Bernard Le Roux failed to gather a line-out. The big lock watched forlornly as McInally raced onto the loose ball and across the line for Scotland's third try, again converted by Hastings.

The French did have one last cheer five minutes from the end when skipper Charles Ollivon crossed over after a swift counter-attack but it was the Scots making all the noise at full-time.


Gregor Townsend declared there is more to come from Scotland after seeing his side put the brakes on France's Grand Slam quest.

Having started their Guinness Six Nations campaign with defeats to Ireland and England, things have taken a turn for the better for the Scots after they followed up victory in Rome with an impressive 28-17 triumph over Les Bleus.

Fabien Galthie's new-look outfit took the lead against the run of play thanks to Damian Penaud's try.

But Mohamed Haouas' moment of madness swung the game back in the Scots' favour, the prop red-carded for landing a punch on Jamie Ritchie's chin.

Townsend's men have struggled to make the most of their attacking opportunities this campaign but, with just 14 men to contend with, they finally found their verve.

Sean Maitland crossed in the minutes either side of half-time before Stuart McInally sealed a precious win that ended the visitors' hopes of a first clean sweep since 2010.

Now the Scotland boss is predicting more of the same when his side travel south for next Saturday's game in Wales.

"I've been really encouraged right the way through the campaign," Townsend said. "The two weeks before the Ireland game was shown in the way we played, how physical we were and how we were able to play at a real pace and create opportunities.

"Yeah, we didn't win and left a couple of tries out there, but we've been consistent throughout. Even the England game, we were proud of how we came back in that second half.

"We have been in the fight in those two defeats. But these two wins showed the mentality and confidence to get out and find a way to win.

"And there's more to come, more defensively even though we're doing that area well.

"You get confidence when you see the rewards you get for doing something, and the way we're training, it really gives me a lot of encouragement."

The sending-off was a turning point but Scotland had been on top from the start.

Adam Hastings continues to grow at stand-off in Finn Russell's absence, Hamish Watson and Ritchie made themselves a menace with their breakdown skulduggery while new skipper Stuart Hogg looks more and more comfortable with the captaincy as the weeks go by.

And Townsend reckons it would be harsh on his team to see their performance diminished by too much focus on Haouas' act of folly.

He said: "Obviously (the red card) is important but I thought we played better in the first half than the second half.

"We had France on the back foot and we turned them over nine times in the first half in the way we defended, and we had opportunities getting in behind them.

"Sometimes a red card can really help you, but I felt France coped with being one man down. It gave them a bit of a kick-start to play more rugby to try and win.

"They're a very dangerous team when they're offloading and counter-attacking. Who knows? If you have a one-man advantage it's better than having the same numbers but I thought we played really well when it was 15 against 15."

Scotland will now aim to make it three wins on the trot at the Principality Stadium - and Townsend hopes the coronavirus will not throw a spanner in the works.

England's trip to Italy has already been called off amid fears over the outbreak but Townsend has heard nothing so far to suggest the Dark Blues' final game of the tournament is under threat.

"Six days, a lot can change," he said. "We'll see. We're not crossing any borders, we hope the game will go ahead because you put a lot of work into a championship to make sure you play all the games, but the decision will obviously be made for the right reasons."


Highlights: Scotland v France | Guinness Six Nations

Like what you've read?
Help your friends Know It All by sharing this article to your social media.

Most Read