21/11/09 22:53 GMT
  £30 Free Bet Latest Odds ATP Masters Bet Now Competitions Sky Games Video
 
 TENNIS NEWS
Picture Safina - still the WTA's world number one.

STANDING UP FOR SAFINA

By Andy Schooler

Send your feedback to: tennisfeedback@sportinglife.com
Click here for full Net Talk blog

Serena Williams' victory at Wimbledon means she is now the owner of three of the four Grand Slam trophies, yet still she has to play second fiddle in the world rankings.

If was a fact brought up in the wake of her 11th Grand Slam singles triumph in SW19 and that was hardly the first time commentators and pundits had criticised the WTA's ranking system over the course of the Wimbledon fortnight.

While the reigning number one, Dinara Safina, hardly did her case much good with her feeble collapse to Williams' sister Venus in the semi-finals at Wimbledon, she is there for a reason.

OK, she remains Slam-less - that seemed to be the biggest cause for concern among those critical of the system at the All England Club - but I for one am more than happy to leap to the defence of the Russian, who certainly seemed to get a raw deal from the media over the past few weeks.

What often weren't discussed on TV commentaries and in newspaper columns were the details behind the ranking system. The general criticism which seemed to be levelled at the WTA was 'it's obvious you have the wrong player as your number one, why?'

I certainly remember BBC commentator David Mercer, in the wake of Safina's semi-final surrender, stressing how the Grand Slam are the pinnacles of his sport.

But that view is already well reflected in the ranking system - there are twice the amount of points on offer at a Grand Slam event than there are at the next highest level of tournament (Premier Mandatory) on the WTA Tour.

Perhaps David wants to increase this to three or four-fold - and he would have a point - but think what that would do to the rest of the tour. Wouldn't it just make the events outside the Slams all rather meaningless?

The Williams sisters are masters at turning up at the big events and performing, but they have been criticised in the past for not supporting the tour as a whole. Were such a points change to be introduced, surely even more of the top players would not show up in places such as Indian Wells, Tokyo and Moscow - and that's before you start to mention the lower-tier events in far-flung places across the globe such as Tashkent and Bogota.

OK, the really big stars such as the Williamses would not suffer, but certainly players lower down the scale would - the reason tennis is the best-paid female sport is not just down to the four Grand Slams. It is the fact that people across the world get to see the players compete on a regular basis. TV companies pay big money to tap into its popularity by showing the tournaments. However, the big bucks becomes small bucks if the top players play less and less.

Essentially the reason Safina is currently top of the pile is that her commitment and level of performance on the tour as a whole is better.

Her Grand Slam results may not have brought the three trophies Williams has collected, but they have hardly been shabby. Two finals (both lost) and two semis in the last 12 months.

Where she has picked up the extra few points currently keeping her above Williams is elsewhere - four other finals, two of which have been won. Serena has reached just one other final on the tour this season. Her claycourt results were once again pretty poor.

Another argument being bandied around was that a Grand Slam winner should earn significantly more points than those getting knocked out in the semis. Again, that already happens. Serena picked up 2,000 points for winning the final; Safina took 900 for her run to the last four.

Personally, I don't see a great deal wrong with the ranking system.

Were you to get players playing just a handful of big events and doing well enough to top the pile, you'd soon have the anti-argument that the rankings did not reward the likes of Safina.

No system is perfect and it's easy to see the current one being tweaked, but it's not the disaster some people have been trying to make out.

Should Serena Williams be ranked as world number one? And what changes would you make to the ranking system to improve it? Send us your comments to: tennisfeedback@sportinglife.com.

E-mail this article E-mail Article Print this article Print-Friendly Subscribe to sportinglife RSS feed Subscribe to RSS Feed
Digg this story post this story to del.icio.us - social bookmarking site Post to del.icio.us Facebook

Click here to send us your sporting feedback

  Latest Tennis Stories
 ANDY MURRAY REFUSES TO CHANGE TACK
 CHAMP DJOKOVIC READY FOR PRESSURE
 FED DISMISSES TALK OF RAFA DEMISE
 MURRAY SET FOR LONDON SHOWCASE
 AGASSI CASE IS CLOSED - ATP
 DEL POTRO HOPES TO REIGN AT QUEEN'S
 KUZNETSOVA WILL PLAY IN SYDNEY
 MURRAY TO OPEN TOUR FINALS
 MURRAY TO FACE FEDERER IN LONDON
 BELGIAN PAIR CONTEST BANS

----------------------------------------------------------------
Part of 365 Media Group

Sports News & Entertainment
Sporting Life | TEAMtalk | Sportal | Football365 | Cricket365
Golf365 | Fixtures365 | Extreme365 | Planet F1 | Planet Rugby | Sky Sports | Football365 ZA

Betting & Gaming
Betting Zone | WSOP |Sky Bet | Poker | Online Casino | Online Bingo | Oddschecker | Casino Checker | Poker Checker | Bingo Checker | Free Bets

Mobile, Fun & Games
Free Online Games | 24-7 Football | Fantasy Football | Fantasy F1
----------------------------------------------------------------

© 2009 365 Media Group Ltd, All Rights Reserved.
Email Your Comments - Advertise With Us - About/Contact Us
Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy - RSS


Watch Live Tennis!
Watch The ATP World Tour Finals Live On The Sky Bet Player!
Net Talk!
Email Us Your Top Women's Matches Of The Year!
Sky Bet Special!
Bet £30, Get £30 Free!
Watch Tennis Free Online!
ATP World Tour Finals
Watch Live Online
Latest Results
Group Standings
Photo Galleries
WTA Tour Championships
Final Flourish For Serena
Final A Family Affair
Trio Reach Last Four
Serena Surges Into Semis
Safina Backs Out
Venus Stunned By Elena
Final Group Standings
Net Talk Comment Column
Columns
WTA Matches Of The Year
Lessons From Doha
WTA Digs Its Own Hole
Ten Seismic Shocks
Clijsters' American Dream
Henin To Spread Fear Factor
End Of An Era Looming?
Murray Feeling The Heat
Safina: No.1 Entertainer
Who's Got Their Eye In?
Doping Stance Softening?
Serena & The Will To Win
Standing Up For Safina
Federer Simply The Best
Murray Needs More
Which Way Will Robson Go?
Kim's Return Most Welcome
WTA Bans: The Reality
Ten Classic Epics
Full Net Talk Blog
2009 ATP Tour Tips
2009 WTA Tour Tips
2009 Archive
US Open
Del Potro Stuns Federer
Kim The Comeback Queen
Full Microsite
Wimbledon
History For Champ Roger
Serena Slays Sister
Full Microsite
French Open
Fed Seals Career Slam
Kuznetsova Crowned Queen
Full Microsite
Australian Open
Nadal Edges Out Fed
Supreme Serena
Results In Full
Other Events
ATP Tour
WTA Tour
2008 Archive
US Open
Five For Federer
Serena Reigns Again
Results In Full
Wimbledon
Nadal Wins Thriller
Venus Sinks Sister
Special Microsite
French Open
Four-Star Nadal
Ana Sinks Safina
Results In Full
Australian Open
Djokovic Delivers
Sharapova Shines
Results In Full
Other Events
ATP Tour
WTA Tour
2007 Archive
US Open
Fed's Four In A Row
Justine Reigns Again
Wimbledon
Fab Five For Fed
Glory For Venus
Special Site
French Open
Rafa Retains Crown
Henin's Title Hat-trick
Australian Open
More History For Federer
Serena Simply Stunning
Other Events
ATP Tour
WTA Tour
2006 Archive
US Open
Three In A Row For Fed
Marvellous Maria
Wimbledon
Fed Wins Fourth Title
Magical Mauresmo
Special Site
French Open
Rafa Reigns Again
Title Treble For Justine
Australian Open
Roger Reigns Again
Mauresmo's Major Break
Other Events
ATP Tour
WTA Tour
2005 Archive
US Open
Fed Express Delivers
Kim Triumphs At Last
Wimbledon
Hat-Trick For Federer
Venus Rises Again
Special Site
French Open
Nadal Crowned King
Justine Reigns Again
Australian Open
Super Safin Crowned
Serena Regains Title
Other Events
ATP Tour
WTA Tour
Tennis Betting
Place Your Bets
Latest News/Previews
Latest Odds