Duncan Ferguson lasted just 10 minutes before he was sent off during the
second half as Everton saw their hopes of going second in the Barclays
Premiership ended by a 2-0 defeat to in-form Charlton at The Valley.
Talal El Karkouri had headed the home side into the lead when the Scot elbowed
Hermann Hreidarsson in the face, and left referee Mike Riley with little option
but to show him a straight red card.
The Charlton full-back had the final word, however, sweeping home a second
goal to complete the win with six minutes left and leave the Addicks on course
for the top six.
Both sides had played five in midfield, and so it was no surprise the opening
exchanges were somewhat scrappy.
It was not until the 10th minute that the first moment of goalmouth action
finally arrived.
Charlton winger Jerome Thomas skipped clear on the left, before his surging
run towards the Everton box was brought to a halt when he was upended by David
Weir.
Danny Murphy rolled the resulting free-kick to El Karkouri, only for Lee
Carsley to charge down the Moroccan's drive. The ball cannoned into the wall,
back out to Thomas and his shot then deflected off Jonathan Fortune and behind
for a goal kick.
The visitors showed plenty of work in the middle of the park, and got men
forward in support of Marcus Bent often enough, but quality was lacking in their
final pass.
However, a slip by Jon Fortune as he jumped into a tackle almost saw Everton
take the lead after quarter of an hour. The ball broke to Bent 25 yards out and
the former Ipswich man took a touch before sending in a low drive, which Dean
Kiely had to touch behind at full stretch down to his left.
When Charlton finally delivered the ball into the danger area, Shaun Bartlett
could not keep his six-yard header down.
The tempo of the match dipped significantly after the half-hour mark, with
both sides again guilty of some sloppy distribution following what had been
positive build-up.
With nine minutes to go until the break, Thomas Gravesen almost collected Tony
Hibbert's intelligent pass into the Charlton box. However, the Dane was well
marshalled by Fortune and the ball eventually was cleared.
As the first half drew to a close, Everton goalkeeper Nigel Martyn was forced
off with what looked like a pulled muscle in his thigh, which gave former
England international Richard Wright a rare taste of first-team football.
Following the restart, in the 58th minute, Thomas had a half-chance when the
ball fell to him at the back post around 12 yards out. However, the former
Arsenal player snapped at his effort, which flew well wide and high.
Murphy almost released Dennis Rommedahl into the Everton box just after the
hour, but his chipped pass was slightly over hit and ran through to Wright.
There was then a massive let-off for the home side following an Everton corner
from the right.
Kiely flapped at the near-post delivery, with El Karkouri needing to hack the
ball away from under the goal. However, it cannoned off Matt Holland and bounced
back towards the line, where Hreidarsson was on hand to smash the ball clear.
Radostin Kishishev forced a good stop from Wright when he sent in a 25-yard
drive. The ex-Ipswich and Arsenal keeper was again called into action in the
73rd minute when Murphy released Bartlett behind the Everton defence after a
slip by Lee Carsley on by-line.
Wright, though, did well to close down the angle at the near post and make an
important block before tipping Rommedahl's cross-cum-shot over.
However, he could do little to stop El Karkouri when the Moroccan powered in a
close-range header from substitute Paul Konchesky's cut-back after Everton had
failed to clear a corner.
The visitors' day went from bad to worse when Ferguson, only on for Bent 10
minutes earlier, was shown a straight red after elbowing Hreidarsson as the pair
tussled for position at a throw-in.
The Charlton full-back showed no ill-effects from the horrendous challenge,
though, as he swept the ball home at the far post following a corner six minutes
from time to extend Charlton's unbeaten run to five games.
Teams
Charlton Kiely, Young, El Karkouri, Fortune, Hreidarsson,
Rommedahl (Konchesky 79), Murphy, Kishishev, Holland,
Thomas (Euell 69), Bartlett.
Subs Not Used: Andersen, Hughes, Johansson.
Goals: El Karkouri 82, Hreidarsson 85.
Everton Martyn (Wright 45), Hibbert, Stubbs, Weir, Pistone,
Yobo (McFadden 84), Carsley, Gravesen, Cahill, Kilbane,
Bent (Ferguson 74).
Subs Not Used: Campbell, Naysmith.
Sent Off: Ferguson (83).
Att: 27,001
Ref: M Riley (W Yorkshire).