It was a match which ended in the most unsavoury manner.
Everton's David Unsworth received a red card in injury time for a grappling
bout with Chelsea winger Jesper Gronkjaer which saw Everton manager David Moyes
step from the touchline to help separate the two players.
Unsworth was told to walk by referee Eddie Wolstenholme while Gronkjaer
received the yellow card before proceeding to add the final nail in a depressing
Goodison afternoon by racing away to add the third goal.
Mario Stanic and Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink had supplied first half goals with
Everton's Gary Naysmith providing Everton's consolation.
But forget the goals. This was a match which confirmed two things.
First, Chelsea manager Claudio Ranieri has augmented the Londoners' trademark
style with a measure of steel which has not been seen down the Kings Road for
many years.
It is a blend which promises to bring Champions League football to Stamford
Bridge even if the main domestic prize might prove too elusive.
Second, don't write off Everton. This might have been their third consecutive
defeat and their first loss at Goodison this season but there is still much that
is impressive about Moyes side.
What a pity it ended as it did, because it should have been an afternoon of
celebration at Goodison as Unsworth accepted a gong for his 300th Everton
appearance and Moyes celebrated his manager of the month award.
As so often happens, however, the party turned to tears as Everton were beaten
for the second time in a week by a Chelsea side who confirmed themselves as
title contenders by surging to second place in the Premiership.
At the end the Everton fans were left indignant at some bizarre refereeing
decisions but there was no questioning the Goodison heart for a battle.
Moyes had moved teenager Wayne Rooney back to the substitutes' bench after his
penalty miss in midweek - Kevin Campbell and Tomasz Radzinski resuming the
striking partnership which has seen Everton look such a potent force this
season.
For Chelsea, unbeaten in seven games and looking increasingly like title
contenders this past month, the evergreen Gianfranco Zola - the Premiership's
joint leading scorer with nine goals at the start of play - again occupied a
striking position alongside Hasselbaink, who scored twice in their midweek
triumph.
But it is the Chelsea defence which has been such a revelation under Ranieri
this term and much of their solidity has been provided by captain Marcel
Desailly and central defensive partner William Gallas, the pair referred to as
'a rock' and 'a hard place' by appreciative Chelsea fans.
As it happens it was Chelsea who took the lead after just five minutes when
the Everton defence failed dismally to repel a Graeme Le Saux corner.
The inswinger swirled savagely into the six-yard box, took a fortuitous flick
off Everton's Thomas Gravesen and popped up invitingly for Stanic, the
30-year-old from Sarajevo but signed from Parma, to head home past goalkeeper
Richard Wright.
It was no more than Chelsea deserved after a bright and inventive start and
while Everton proceeded to show the steel which Moyes has galvanised at Goodison
it was Chelsea who cashed in on their superior invention after 27 minutes.
This time it was Frank Lampard who raced on to a loose ball at the edge of the
area as Everton defenders ball-watched to allow the Chelsea midfielder to
thunder a stinging 20-yarder at Wright.
So fierce was the shot that the Everton goalkeeper could only parry the ball
in front of him and as it ran loose Hasselbaink was the first to react - the
Dutch striker sliding a right-foot shot into the corner of the net to stretch
Chelsea's lead.
The Everton soldiers of old might have laid down their arms at that point but
not this commando unit Moyes has assembled at Goodison.
They merely dug in, formed a fresh bridgehead and then poured forward in
increasing numbers.
Chelsea struggled to stem the onslaught and it was almost inevitable when the
Merseysiders fashioned a toe-hold in the game just two minutes before
half-time.
It was a swift interchange of passes on the edge of the box this time which
put Naysmith one-on-one with Cudicini and the Everton midfielder took his time
before guiding his angled shot past the Chelsea goalkeeper's out-stretched
right-hand.
The Everton attitude in the second-half could not be faulted.
Moyes threw on Wayne Rooney for Radzinski in the 63rd minute for Radzinski and
also introduced Scot Gemmill.
Soon after Campbell might have eased the home frustration when he launched
himself at a Gravesen long throw but could not steer his header past Cudicini.
Moments later the big striker had an ever better chance, this time latching
onto a loose ball inside the six-yard area and hitting his shot into the
ground.
The ball bounced over Cudicini's arm and appeared goalbound, only for Le Saux
to stick out his foot and clear off the line. Le Saux was on hand two minutes
later with similar effect to deprive Carsley.
And after 71 minutes Campbell hit the post with a thrusting effort as Everton
threw everything at Chelsea in a desperate effort to salvage a point.
With Rooney supplying a couple of weaving runs and Gravesen providing the
energy it seemed Everton must equalise.
But, while Gallas and Desailly rode their luck, they prevailed until the final
explosive moments saw Everton self-destruct.
It was never that sort of game. Rather it was a tense and frantic battle
between two sides who will be there or thereabouts come May.
>B>Teams:
Everton: Wright, Hibbert, Yobo, Stubbs, Unsworth, Carsley,
Tie Li (Gemmill 63), Gravesen, Naysmith, Radzinski (Rooney 63),
Campbell.
Subs Not Used: Pistone, Weir, Simonsen.
Sent Off: Unsworth (90).
Booked: Stubbs.
Goals: Naysmith 43.
Chelsea: Cudicini, Melchiot, Gallas, Desailly, Le Saux,
Lampard, Stanic (Gronkjaer 60), Petit, De Lucas (Terry 76),
Hasselbaink (Gudjohnsen 84), Zola.
Subs Not Used: de Goey, Morris.
Booked: Stanic, De Lucas, Gallas, Hasselbaink, Lampard,
Gronkjaer.
Goals: Stanic 5, Hasselbaink 28, Gronkjaer 90.
Att: 39,396
Ref: E Wolstenholme (Lancashire).